Film Review: The Reluctant Fundamentalist

by Ambrose W. Benkert

In such works as Salaam Bombay and The Namesake, director Mira Nair has shown herself to be a gifted filmmaker. She brings that sure touch to her latest work, The Reluctant Fundamentalist, based on a novel by Mohsin Hamid.

This is an uncommonly intelligent and honest film. Hamid could have compromised the film by making it more commercial, but she didn't. A substantial part of the film is in Urdu, the language of Pakistan. Showing a sympathetic Pakistani character in the aftermath of 9/11 may discomfort some viewers, while others may object to the rapacious capitalism practiced by the protagonist's investment bank.

The cast is uniformly excellent, particularly Riz Ahmed, a British actor of Pakistani descent, in the pivotal role of Changez. Director Mira Nair begins the film as a character study that slowly morphs into a thriller in such an organic way that it doesn't feel contrived.

The film depicts the rise of Changez (Riz Ahmed), the ambitious son of a prominent Pakistani poet who graduates from Princeton before 9/11 and lands a job in New York as a financial analyst with a prestigious investment bank. His acerbic boss (Kiefer Sutherland) takes him under his wing, recognizing Changez's savvy and diligence. 

The attack on the World Trade Center occurs while Changez is on assignment in the Phillippines. Subjected to indignities and viewed with suspicion for simply being a young Muslim man, Changez still loves America but feels that America does not love him back. 

We next assignment see on assignment in Istanbul. Confronted with the dilemma of having to recommend closing a bookstore that happens to sell his father's poetry, Changez quits his job and returns to his native Lahore. He takes a position as a professor of finance at a local university. But when his American supervisor goes missing, Changez must choose between his native country and the one that provided his education and professional training. The film climaxes in a tense confrontation between Changez and a CIA agent (Liev Schreiber).

The only false note in this film is the contrived plot device that breaks up Changez's relationship with his onscreen girlfriend, Erica (Kate Hudson).

You're unlikely to see a better evocation of the dichotomy between Muslim and Western culture than The Reluctant Fundamentalist. This protagonist has a foot in each world and he's placed in the awjward position of having to choose between them. 

Edited by Julie A. Ashcraft

(c) 2013 Julie A. Ashcraft

All rights reserved. 

Olympus Has Fallen and It Can't Get Up

by Ambrose W. Benkert, Jr.

By featuring the White House as the battlefield, the makers of Olympus Has Fallen spin the film as a political thriller -- but it's nothing of the sort. In this film, humans are reduced to one-dimensional characters who fall flat in the thin plot while the constant bombardment of spectacular special effects, murder and mayhem manipulate the audience into reacting emotionally without a moment of contemplative thought. Olympus Has Fallen is as suspenseless as it is senseless, offering none of the foreshadowing characteristic of classic thrillers that allowed viewers the pleasure of imagining strategies to cope with the dilemmas presented onscreen.

In Olympus Has Fallen a delegation lead by the South Korean Prime Minister visits the White House. Unbeknownst to him, a North Korean operative -- "one of the most wanted terrorists in the world" -- has infiltrated his entourage. With the help of a rogue American Secret Service agent and fellow North Koreans, the terrorist takes the American President, Vice President, Secretary of Defense and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs hostage. He demands that the United States withdraw its forces from Korea, withdraw the Seventh Fleet from the surrounding waters and give North Korea the USA nuclear weapons launch codes. They torture the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs and the Secretary of Defense in an effort to get the codes.

American Secret Service Agent Mike Banning, played by Gerard Butler, sees the takeover as an opportunity to revive his career. Banning had been relieved of his duties protecting the President because of his failure to prevent the death of the First Lady when her car skidded off a bridge. Banning goes to the White House and essentially functions as a one-man commando squad for the remainder of the film.

To say that the film's political sophistication is of a junior high school level would be to insult junior high students. When the rogue agent played by Dylan McDermott is asked to explain his treachery, he murmurs something incoherent about globalization, and he asks how much the president spent on his last election --"$500 million?"  (Based on the 2012 election that would be cheap).  At this point you want to jump in and ask how turning the country over to the North Koreans would alleviate the effects of globalization, but that would involve logical thought, which is in short supply in Olympus Has Fallen. 

The leader of the North Koreans, played by Rick Yune, attempts to justify his actions by saying that America should know famine the way his homeland does. Any suggestion that the cult of personality developed by the various Kims who have ruled in Pyongyang bears some responsibility for their nation's suffering is wholly absent.

Most of the cast is wasted. Aaron Eckhart displayed a deft touch in such films as Thank You For Smoking and The Dark Knight. But in Olympus Has Fallen Eckhart is reduced to playing an American President who glares angrily at his tormentors and later receives a standing ovation from the press corps for his cliche-ridden speech about the greatness of America. The American Vice President (Phil Austin) is so underwritten that the character might as well not be in the film. After being beaten to a pulp, the Secretary of Defense (Melissa Leo) semi-coherently recites the Pledge of Allegiance while she's dragged through the corpse-strewn corridors of the White House. Morgan Freeman plays the Speaker of the House who fulfills his Constitutional authority by taking over the duties of the President and Vice President, so he must decide whether to accede to the terrorists' demands. Freeman seems miscast since he's more a man of contemplation than a man of action -- and this is the ultimate action film.

In summary, Olympus Has Fallen is entertaining in the way that some video games are. The hi-tech weaponry and the special effects overload the visual senses and keep the pulse racing. I've rarely seen a film with this many dead bodies. The film is set in July, so one would expect the stench from the rotting corpses to be overpowering, even in the air-conditioned White House. This film exploits visceral thrills in a political setting, but it's more about gore and shock than political ideas.

Edited by Julie A. Ashcraft
(c) 2013 Julie A. Ashcraft
All rights reserved

10 Questions for Iran's President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad

http://youtu.be/BOozNsuzGVM

"Manhattan Project" Video Explores Consequences of Money War

Hip Hop Meets Neue Deutsche Welle: Ja Ja Ja

Julie Jigsaw onstage with Ja Ja Ja. Photo: Ar/Gee Gleim

Julie Jigsaw became the first female rapper on record in Europe, and  the first rapper to record a song about graffiti in Europe, with the releases of JaJaJa “Katz Rap” and “Graffiti Artists Inter-national” in 1982.

Julie Jigsaw was my stage name with Ja Ja Ja. My real name is Julie A. Ashcraft. And I'm currently recording under the name Jigsawnovich.

          In 1980, I left Dallas for Pratt Institute in New York, and co-founded my first band, Group of Trees, there with fellow art students Ted Parsons on drums and Gregory Grinnell on guitar. I wrote all the lyrics and the melodies that I sang and played on Casiotone. Our sound was Post-Punk/No-Wave with a Surf influence. Ted later joined The Swans and Prong. Greg later joined The Toasters. 

          From 1978-1980, I saw Liquid Liquid, Siouxsie and the Banshees, The Slits, Patti Smith, Captain Beefheart and Devo live on stage. I was one of the first girls to slam dance, or "mosh" as it was later called, in New York--while attending Bad Brains concerts with my friend John Joseph McGowan, who went on to be lead singer of The Cro-Mags. I met Steve Ignorant by chance when I wore a CRASS badge to the Reggae Lounge in New York. Steve wrote letters to me for the next year.

          The CRASS logo and the Danceteria club logo were designed by artist David King. He and his wife kindly let me crash at their place in Soho after nightclubbing, rather than taking dangerous late night subway rides back to Brooklyn. Myrtle Avenue, near my home and college campus, was nicknamed "Murder Avenue." All my art school friends had been mugged or robbed, but I had not. This may have been due to the wildly colored and patterned Mod and leather Punk Rock clothes I wore, which made me look more fierce. The dark-skinned people in the neighborhood seemed to enjoy my fashions, smiling and making remarks such as, "girl, you're lit up like a Jack O'lantern," or "hey, Sid Vicious" when I walked by.

          Boom boxes and car audio systems filled the streets of New York with the latest rap and Hip Hop breaks. On the weekends, I visited Bethesda Fountain Terrace in Central Park to watch break dancers and disco roller skaters. 

          I also listened to Chinese Opera, Yoko Ono, Der Plan, Deutsch Amerikan- ische Freundschaft, Holger Hiller, Wirt- schaftswunder, Sugarhill Gang, The Surfaris, ? and the Mysterians, The Residents, Kraftwerk, Mars, DNA, PIL, Wire, Joy Division, Augustus Pablo and Ornette Coleman. I was a radio dj with a weekly show on Pratt Radio’s original WPIR station. Fellow art student Daniel Clowes let me borrow records to play on air, and I half starved myself in order to afford new imports at 99 Records. 

          In 1980, I purchased Der Plan's Geri Reig record because the robot baby Jesus on the cover was funny! I also liked the sound of German, and tried to learn it by listening to Der Plan. I wrote them a fan letter, complimenting their artwork and asking how they made all the interesting sounds in the music. Moritz R., the graphic artist and lead singer of Der Plan, replied. After we exchanged letters, photos and cassette tapes for months, Moritz invited me to visit him and Der Plan.

          I flew to Dusseldorf, and I stayed in the guest room at ATA TAK studios, downstairs from Kurt Dahlke (A.K.A. Pyrolator) and Frank Fenstermacher. I enjoyed deep philosophical conversations with Frank and Kurt. George Gurdjieff concepts Kurt told me about, regarding "identification,” inspired me to write a poem which later became the lyrics to the "Ja! Ja! Ja!" (Yes! Yes! Yes!) song.

Cassette with Ja Ja Ja's first song, "Die Wahrheit."

          While in Germany, I heard "Maschine brennt" and "Der Kommissar" by Falco, "Rap- ture" by Blondie and "The Message" by Grandmaster Flash. These songs proved that Rap had interna- tional appeal.

          I wrote new melodies on piano and rhythms on drums, and experimented with the bass, trumpet and synthesizer in the ATA TAK studio. Frank called me a "natural talent," and Kurt introduced me to his friends, Frank Samba and Wietn Wito. The first night we met, Frank, Wito and I had a jam session. I improvised lyrics and sang, played harmonica, percussion and trumpet; Wito played bass; and Frank played drums. Kurt/Pyrolator slipped into the booth and recorded us. We chose the best parts, and Wito suggested we call it, "Die Wahrheit” (The Truth). It would be our first single, released in 1982 on the Klar! 80 Sampler, ALLES ODER NICHTS (EVERYTHING OR NOTHING).
  
          In the next days Frank, Wito and I created "Katz Rap"(Cat Rap)  and "Mom", which would be released as our 7" single, on ATA TAK, engineered by Pyrolator. I suggested our band name, Ja Ja Ja, and I designed and painted the Katz Rap record sleeve and label. 

"Katz Rap" featured the first female Rapper in Europe

          With the 1982 release of "Katz Rap," I be- came the first female rapper on record in Europe,and one of the earliest white persons to make a rap record. With the release of "Graffiti Artists Interna- tional" later that year, I became the first rapper in Europe to record a song about graffiti. I was one of the earliest white persons to make a rap record, preceded by Deborah Harry, Falco, and Futura 2000. The record cover I designed and painted for our album was one of the first record covers to depict a dinosaur, and it long preceded David Icke's hypothesis regarding reptilians and technology. I also painted the large dinosaur and graffiti backdrop we exhibited at our live shows. And I created a breakdancing dinosaur concept for our “I Am An Animal” video. 

The Ja Ja Ja album included the first rap song
about graffiti in Europe.

          1981-1982, I met Blixa Bargeld, Gudrun Gut, Bettina Koster, Robert Gorl, Werner Lambertz, and Andreas Dorau. I interviewed Holger Hiller for the New Musical Express, and I saw Palais Schaumburg, Einsturzende Neubauten and Der KFC live onstage. I also visited both East and West Berlin as often as possible. The vibrant politics and fiery squatter riots on the Western side contrasted with private acts of rebellion against the paranoid Stasi state on the Eastern side were fascinating. In the meanwhile the cold war nuclear arms race was accelerating, and some of the young Germans I met resented what they saw as “occupation” via American military bases. This tense atmosphere inspired my lyrics to “Habt Nicht Mehr Angst” (Have No More Fear).

Frank Samba, Julie Jigsaw, Wietn Wito
of Ja Ja Ja

          New poems I wrote in Germany, plus poems I'd written in New York, became lyrics for all the Ja Ja Ja songs. I presented deeply personal experiences and emotions in an abstract and sometimes lighthearted manner, to show a way to survive and even find joy in such intensity. I composed the melodies I sang and played, and I composed the melody that Wito played on "Destiny." He and Frank tended to play their instruments in ways that were at once rhythmic and melodic. Frank tuned his drums with great precision, and he was acutely aware of overtones and harmonics. Wito created infectious, driving riffs. Together we pioneered a dynamic new sound, and Ar/Gee Gleim’s photos of us captured our affectionate spirit.

Years before he engineered Bjork, The Sugarcubes and Kukl, Mel Jefferson was the recording engineer for Ja Ja Ja. In 1982, while we were recording our album, Mel suggested that I sing harmonies like a train in the distance, for the opening section of "Graffiti Artists International". I've always wondered whether The Pixies "Where is My Mind,” Fierce & Nico “Input,” and Hichkas "Terrorist" included samples of my voice from "Graffiti Artists International".

          Wito and Frank, and our featured guest, Henry Scott III, were tremendous musicians. Playing live was great! It was so nice seeing our audiences, and finding that such an amazing mixture of many different kinds of people enjoy our music! I remember a gig in Zurich where our audience was half leather clad Punk Rockers and half engineers/scientists wearing glasses and nicely pressed shirts! We played clubs, colleges and festivals in Germany, Holland, Switzerland, Belgium—and we attracted fans from many other countries! And Melle Mel from Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five attended our concerts at the Danceteria club in New York City. John Peel played “Katz Rap” on BBC radio and we were interviewed on German Radio in Zurich. 

          I also had the pleasure of being featured on a track by Austrian musician Xao Seffcheque. His warmth and sense of humor were rare in Dusseldorf. I wrote the lyrics and sang on Xao’s track, "Julie in Germany," which was released in 1982 on the Klar und Wahr - Sounds Rettet Deutschland (Clear and True - Sounds Rescues Germany) compilation released by Das Buro.

           Although I'd written the lyrics and melodies to most of the Ja Ja Ja songs, rather than only giving Frank and Wito arrangements credits, we split songwriting credits on our singles and album three ways in order to encourage collaboration. Afterwards, Wito came to me and said he’d written some new songs, that he would dictate what I would play and sing, and that he wanted the songs credited to himself only. His proposal was dictatorial and in violation of our agreement regarding collaborative credits. Besides, Wito was focusing on Prog Jazz, whereas I was more interested in Hip Hop. 

In 1983, I moved back to New York and became involved in the New York Hip Hop movement, exploring my talents as a Graffiti Artist. I painted fifty jackets for the Allen Boys; and became friends with Revolt and Lee Quinones. My paintings and sculptures were included in shows at Fashion Moda, Danceteria and Stellweg Seguy. I collaborated on a mural with Lady Pink in The Roxy. Cey and Sharp took me down subway tunnels and we painted graffiti pieces on the sides of the train. Futura 2000 and Zephyr drew full pages in my graffiti blackbooks. Cey introduced me to Andy Warhol, Jean Michele Basquiat, and Keith Haring. My friend Martin Burgoyne, from Pratt Institute, introduced me to Madonna.

          During 1983-84 was living on Riving- ton Street, dodging stray bullets and listening to the new hard rap from Run DMC. Inspired by the danger of the Lower East Side of Manhattan, I wrote new songs. Frank and I found American bassist Billy Grant to replace Wito. We toured and were well received. If only the internet had existed at that time! Keeping the group together with an ocean between Frank and me proved too difficult in the end. 

          Ja Ja Ja is a group full of joy and emotional struggles, perfection and experimentation, space and time. The combination of our souls and skills sometimes created fields of virtually metaphysical intensity and magnitude. Wito told me he saw colors rise from his bass into the air and go out into the audience. Our music has prevailed with your help, beloved listener. Thank you for your inspirational energy and your enthusiasm through the decades. 
          Frank Samba and Kurt Dahlke/Pyrolator are currently remastering our self-titled Ja Ja Ja album, which was originally released in 1982. It will be re-released in Japan soon. "Katz Rap" was re-released on the compilation CD, Grlz: Women Ahead of Their Time (Germany, Crippled Dick Hot Wax Records 2005). One of our original vinyl 7" ATA TAK pressings of "Katz Rap" is included in the Cornell University Library Hip Hop Collection, circa 1975-85, a Division of Rare Manuscript Collections. 

          I've recorded one song under the name Jigsawnovich, and plan to release a new song soon. 
~Julie A. Ashcraft A.K.A. Julie Jigsaw A.K.A. Jigsawnovich

© 2011 Julie A. Ashcraft

All rights reserved. For permissions and more information, contact Julie at jigsawnovich (at) gmail (dot) com

MY 911 SONG

Available for download at Amazon

MAY 1 WORKER'S DAY SIGNS: CLICK TO ENLARGE AND PRINT

World Of Ashcraft

You didn't really think Jigsawnovich was the name my parents gave me, did you? Check out my new blog.
http://worldofashcraft.wordpress.com/2010/10/02/attn-mr-democrat-campaign/

Beer & Rap in Ramallah, Palestine

DAM - Palestinian Hip Hop group performs 8:00 pm today at Taybeh in Ramallah, Palestine

Taybeh Products for sale: Taybeh Beer, Taybeh Honey, Taybeh Olive oil, Too Top Olive oil, Tatreez (embroidery), Maftool (couscous), Thyme (zataar), Peace lamp...

Food at the fest: Shawarma, Falafel, chicken, kabab, kanafeh, BBQ

See Taybeh Oktoberfest 2010 Facebook page for more info.

North Korea: Black Suit vs. Beige

Black vs. Beige: could the color of Kim Jong Il's son's suit mark a symbolic shift towards business, away from militarism?

Democracy Video from Azerbaijan

Ahmadinejad vs. Capitalism...Oh Really?

Although some of dangers of capitalism being too unregulated and very globalized were exposed when the sub-prime housing crisis impacted not only the U.S. but other countries with international investment portfolios, Ahmadinejad's statement against capitalism seems ironic, since Sepah (Revolutionary Guards) are taking over more and more businesses in Iran, already reportedly reaps huge profits off black market items in Iran, and arrests so many people and demands such huge bail that it's starting to look like an extortion racket. Also, the Islamic regime famously persecuted the Communists who helped them come to power.

So is this the best that AN could come up with as a theoretical counter-attack to the more severe economic sanctions that have been put in place against the IRI?


http://news.yahoo.com/video/world-15749633/22013125Ahmadinejad Lashes Out at Capitalism

Rap Satire and Anti-Rap Propaganda: Iranian Rapper, Video Maker, Promoter React

by Julie Jigsawnovich

Rap music and style have been exploited in movies and TV shows approved by Ershad, Iran’s Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance, with depictions that distort and deviate from the spirit of real Iranian rap. I asked Fred, Shaya, and Adrenaline to express their opinions of this material. Farbod "Fred" Khoshtinat created the video for Hichkas’ “Ye Mosht Sarbaz” (Bunch of Soldiers) track [and has since won a 2010 Democracy Video Challenge award and also directed the "Dasa Bala" video for Arash] Shaya may be the only female rapper still trying to create and perform new songs inside Iran. Adrenaline is an underground rap promoter. They do not know each other, and they answered the following questions separately, without seeing each others’ answers.

JJ: How would you describe the “rap” in the trailer for this Iranian government-approved movie, Shame-e Aroosi (Wedding Dinner), which you can see here?

S: I don’t like this. This is a kind of joke.

FK: This is fast rhyming about moral things like weddings and stuff.

A: Honestly, I didn’t even watch it to the end. I can describe it in one word: “garbage”.

JJ: Are you surprised that Ershad allowed “rap” and “graffiti” to be shown in a movie in Iran, when Police there arrest real rappers and graffiti artists?

S: No, but we are sorry when we see these scenes in our movies. They show this just to give some fun to every person that bought a ticket.

FK: The thing that they are against are the lyrics that have been used in rap. And, by the way, you can never see such a thing in Iranian TV. This is Iranian cinema–whole different rules!

A: Sorry that I didn’t put it in a charming, polite way. I don’t care about the governments, because I have seen many crazy things from them that make “inviting Lil’ Wayne for a show in Iran national TV” like nothing. And you don’t need to worry about the POLICE! They can arrest you for ONLY WALKING IN THE STREETS! It’s up to them–they have the right to arrest anyone at anytime if they feel like it! So don’t worry about police arresting graffiti artists!

JJ: Do you think this movie helped or hurt rap in Iran?

S: Absolutely hurts.

FK: I don’t think it has any effect on rap in Iran. I don’t really consider that song a rap!

A: You don’t need to worry about third question either! Because there are only A FEW people–like 15, or maybe 20–in Iran who really know the real hip-hop! So Persian rap is already hurt! We need a miracle here.

JJ: Has rap been shown in any Iranian movies or on Iranian TV lately?

S: I saw some rap music in movies, but they portray rappers as sick people.

FK: No, there is no such a thing as rap in Iranian TV.

A: Sorry, because I don’t watch Iranian TV or movies–NEVER! And I mean it!

JJ: Fred, I heard there was an Iranian TV show called Shock that used HichKas songs. And this TV program was State propaganda–saying all rappers use drugs and are into devil worship. Did you see Shock? Is it true what I heard about that show?

FK: Yes, it’s all true about Shock. It also showed some parts of Hichkas’ “Bunch of Soldiers” music video.

JJ: I heard that rap music was considered “Western music” in Iran, and was therefore forbidden for most rappers to perform. No?

FK: My opinion is that their main concern is on the lyrics. We have legal rock and pop, but they have moral lyrics.

JJ: I think the lyrics to Hichkas’ “Bunch of Soldiers” do show a type of morality. He’s talking about loving God, friends and family–and being ready to defend his country against attack. He is saying he is street wise, but that he has made mistakes. He is not saying anything ****ual, and he is not criticizing the regime. What more could they ask for? Really!

FK: Hichkas is someone outside the system who is leading some people. This is some big political issue. Hichkas is influential, and the regime dislikes this.

JJ: How did you feel when you saw the “Bunch of Soldiers” video you made for Hichkas included in Shock?

FK: I was shocked and amazed. Iranian TV just showed five seconds of the video, where Hichkas is moving his hands fast–while a Shock narrator claimed that drugs made rappers and Satanists mad. It was propaganda to convince the society about arresting the rappers.

JJ: Did the inclusion of the “Bunch of Soldiers” video in Shock help or hurt your career?

FK: It hurt. That inclusion meant that they had their eyes on us–and they really did.

JJ: When did Shock first show on TV?

FK: I think it was summer before last–I’m not sure. But two months after that they started to arrest underground artists, again.

***

From the archives of Oct. 2009

Mashaii vs. Islamist Hardliners

When it comes to pre-Islamic history, music and women's rights, does Mashaii might offer some glimmer of hope? Iranian friends of mine tell me he's even helped give official approval to pop songs somewhat critical of the regime. It's a shame he doesn't like hip hop. I hear that Iranian hip hop musicians are still taking big risks inside Iran.--Jigsawnovich

http://www.payvand.com/news/10/sep/1173.html

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/tehranbureau/2010/09/please-come-back.html

IRI can track Haystack proxy users

Frankly, there are already other proxy servers that internet users in Iran are using safely. I don't see why Haystack was even needed. Now it turns out Haystack may have endangered users. Very sad. Not good.

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-501465_162-20016546-501465.html

Tor developer criticizes Haystack http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/09/haystack

http://haystacky.s3.amazonaws.com/www.oblomovka.com/wp/2010/09/14/haystack-vs-how-the-internet-works/index.html

Democracy Video Challenge winners honored at UN

Had a great time at the Democracy Video Challenge screening at the United Nations. Enjoyed seeing the people I met in DC again, seeing friends I invited and also meeting new people. Congratulations to Farbod Khoshtinat, Taraneh Golozar and Shahin Pajoom for their success with the ATTN: Mr. Democrat video. It's been viewed more than 21,000 times now. I look forward to the day it reaches 100,000 views.

Yazdi: prison rape spiritual equivalent of pilgrimage to Mecca

Grand ayatollah Yazdi is beyond extreme. I hope he does not gain even more power after Khamenei dies.

http://raheazadi.com/1388/06/11/ayatollah-mesbah-yazdi-sodomy-and-rape-of-protesters-is-ok/

VOA interviews Iranian Democracy Video Challenge Winner

Farbod "Fred" Khoshtinat's video, ATTN: Mr. Democrat, is one of six winners of the 2010 Democracy Video Challenge.




Click through for wide screen.

ATTN: Mr. Democrat director receives award from Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton

The sharp truths in Farbod "Fred" Khoshtinat's ATTN: Mr. Democrat video are almost shocking. It's wonderful to see these truths and the greatness of this video acknowledged--and by acknowledging them, the greatness of brave Iranian people who do fight and struggle against exterior and interior obstacles as they seek the way to their own kind of freedom and democracy.

Thanks again to everyone who voted and helped spread the word about this video.

Here is the video link to the Democracy Video Challenge award ceremony. Secretary Rodham Clinton mentions Iran's green movement around 4:00 and Farbod "Fred" Khoshtinat receives the award around 6:18. Here is more info about Democracy Video Challenge.

There are six winners of the 2010 Democracy Video Challenge: Anup Poudel of Nepal, Yared Shumete of Ethiopia, Farbod Khoshtinat of Iran, Joel Ben Marsden of Spain, Adhyatmika Euuy of Indonesia and Juan Pablo Patino Arevelo of Colombia.

Here is the transcript in case your computer/internet connection is too slow for video, or your country blocks YouTube.

2010 Democracy Video Challenge Award Presentation

Hillary Rodham Clinton 


Secretary of State


Judith A. McHale 
Under Secretary for Public Diplomacy and Public Affairs


Treaty Room


Washington, DC September 10, 2010

UNDER SECRETARY MCHALE: Come on in. These are the stars of the show, the real stars of the show. They probably feel a little uncomfortable because they’re normally on the other side of the camera. (Laughter.)

Good afternoon. I’m delighted to be here with all of you today. I’m Judith McHale and I have the great privilege of introducing you to some great filmmakers. These are the winners of our Democracy Video Challenge, which is in its second or third year that we have done this, where we reach out to young filmmakers around the world and ask them to submit videos which illustrate how they think about – the contest is called Democracy Is… and so they interpret in film, in a two-minute film, what democracy means. And it’s absolutely extraordinary. The sort of versions and interpretations of this are really incredibly well done, but also very moving. We have – obviously, all of us have an enormous commitment to democracy and to see how these young filmmakers interpret that world, I invite you all to see it.

We’re also delighted to have some of our partners here with us today, without whom we could not have done it. And I’d also especially like to thank Lori Brutten from IIP, who has organized this, the sort of State Department genius behind this, and Dawn McCall, our new head of IIP, who have joined me here today.

But most importantly, I’m delighted to have our Secretary of State, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, with us today to say a few words about these great filmmakers. Secretary Clinton.

SECRETARY CLINTON: Thank you so much, Judith. And this is an especially exciting day for us here to celebrate these young activist filmmakers who are using technology to make their voices heard and, by doing so, giving voice to so many millions of others, and the State Department’s partners who have made the Democracy Video Challenge not only possible, but amazingly successful.

So far, over 3.5 million people around the world have been reached by our growing Democracy is… campaign. This is an effort led by Judith and her entire team to engage youth in a global dialogue on democracy. And we are about to kick off the 3rd annual Democracy Video Challenge at the United Nations next week. So I am very eager to see what ideas this continues to generate.

The prompt for this challenge, as you know, is “Democracy is…” It’s open ended. It is meant to provoke thought and to spur ideas. It truly is a challenge that builds on the freedom that democracy provides for individuals to pursue their own dreams. Each of these young winners has captured six different visions of democracy – some satirical and lighthearted, some poignant and haunting – but each shaped by their own experiences and expressed through their own unique artistic lens.

Now, not all democracies look or behave exactly the same way. As our winner from Nepal said about his video – I hope you don’t mind me quoting you – (laughter) – “Democracy can exist in all countries and it doesn’t have a fixed shape or size.” But the fundamental tenets are non-negotiable. The videos we are honoring today capture essential truths about democracy across the world and respond to the deepest yearning of human beings to have a right to their own lives and their own dreams. Democracy is about fair play. Democracy equalizes the voices of people. And democracy is a learning process.

And so I said earlier this week at a speech I gave that democracy needs defending. And I think we have a very good cross-section of defenders standing here. Another one of our winners, whose beautiful video was inspired by the Green Movement in Iran, said, “I believe if I want democracy, I should fight for it! And this is my way of fighting.” And it gives me great hope to see what these young people are saying.

Now, here at the State Department, we talk a lot about the need to use 21st century diplomacy to solve 21st century problems. Well, this is the heart of that 21st century diplomacy – connecting directly to people, particularly young people, who Judith constantly reminds me – (laughter) – represents what percentage of the world’s population? (Laughter.)

UNDER SECRETARY MCHALE: Sixty-five percent are under the age of 30.

SECRETARY CLINTON: Yeah. Boy, does that make me feel old, I gotta tell you. (Laughter.)

So this is about not only the next generation, it’s about this generation. I particularly want to welcome representatives of the countries of the winners who are here today, and thank you all for coming.

Now, Under Secretary McHale will come back to officially present the awards, which I think you will call the name and I will hand the award. Is that the way we will do it? So I will maybe come out around here, and as you call the name, if the winner will come up here, and then we can give the award. And I hope you all get pictures – that way? Is that okay? All right.

UNDER SECRETARY MCHALE: As Secretary Clinton has mentioned, these winners come from around the world, from each of the six different regions of the world, and they were voted on by people who were tuned into and watching constantly YouTube. So we also especially want to thank YouTube for helping us with this.

From Colombia, Juan Pablo Patiño. (Applause.)

From Ethiopia, Yared Shumete. (Applause.)

From Indonesia, Adhyatmika. (Applause.)

From Iran, Farbod Khoshtinat. (Applause.)

From Nepal, Anup Poudel. (Applause.)

And from Spain, Jual – I’m sorry, Joel Mardsen. (Applause.)

SECRETARY CLINTON: Well, we’re very proud of these winners and we are looking to follow them with great interest. We hope that this not only confirms their own ideas, but actually serves to generate more from them and encourage others to join their ranks. So let’s give our award winners another round of applause. (Applause.)

And Judith, why don’t we invite some of our partners and perhaps you could introduce them as well.

LORI BRUTTEN: (Inaudible), Steve Grove, the director of YouTube Student Politics; Rick Cotton, Chief Counsel of NBC Universal; Kate Raftery from the – Vice President for Learning and Citizenship at the International Youth Foundation; Patti Pearson, New York University’s Tisch School of the Arts, Director of Special Projects.

SECRETARY CLINTON: Great. (Applause.) Great. Thank you all very much.

# # #